Skip to main content

Table 1 Advantages and disadvantages of three dimensional (3D) and two dimensional (2D) cell culture systems

From: Three-dimensional (3D) cell culture: a valuable step in advancing treatments for human hepatocellular carcinoma

Items

2D cell culture

3D cell culture

Refs.

Disadvantages

Time required for culture formation

Minutes to a few hours

A few hours to a few days

[52]

Quality of culture

Simple long-term culture

Easy to interpret results

High performance and reproducibility

More difficult to culture Difficult to interpret results Poor performance and reproducibility

[53]

Cost of culture maintenance

Less time consuming Inexpensive

Commercially available media and assay materials

More time consuming More expensive

Fewer commercially available assay materials

[44, 45]

Advantages

In vivo imitation

Cannot mimic the natural tumour mass structure

Can mimic in vivo tissue structures

[55]

Cell interactions

No cell–cell or cell- extracellular microenvironment interactions

No “niches” or in vivo-like microenvironment

Appropriate cell–cell and cell-extracellular microenvironment interactions

Microenvironment “niches” are present

[56,57,58]

CellCharacteristics

Altered morphology from physiological tissue

Altered cell division activity

Lack of diverse phenotypes and polarization

Preserved morphology Preserved cell division activity

Presence of diverse phenotypes and polarization

[59, 60]

Access to essential compounds

Limited access to nutrients, oxygen, metabolites, and signalling molecules

Variable access to nutrients, oxygen, metabolites, and signalling molecules

[61, 62]

Molecular mechanisms

Alterations in cellular biochemistry

Alterations in gene expression, mRNA splicing, and topology

Preserved cellular biochemistry

Preserved gene expression, mRNA splicing, and topology

[63, 64]

Angiogenesis

Only observational

Could be functional

[65]

Mathematical model

Possible

Better geometry and structure–function links

[65]